CS-3 — Sustainability, Engineering and the Environment
Engineers need to have knowledge and be conversant with what sustainability means in engineering and for the environment. Topics include: fundamental knowledge of climate change, global warming, and the impact of human activities on soil, air, water quality and resources; knowledge of renewable energy sources; development, and product and materials life cycle assessment; end-of-life potential such as recycling and the reuse of products; design for disassembly, e-waste, and reverse manufacturing. Energy production, greenhouse gas emissions, and types and forms of energy as related to consumption patterns, consumer awareness, and industrial sectors; optimized energy and resources management; sustainable methods; and sustainability indicators; regulatory aspects of environmental management, and ecological planning.
Subject outline
CS-3 Sustainability, Engineering and the Environment is a Complementary Studies technical exam (PEO National Examination 11-CS-3) on the environmental side of engineering practice. The May 2019 and December 2018 papers ask about ground-level and stratospheric ozone, CFCs, primary and secondary air pollutants, particulate matter and acid rain; carbon dioxide equivalents from 100-year global warming potentials, ranked, and actions for climate change mitigation and adaptation; the 12 principles of green engineering, pollution prevention and a factory mass balance; life-cycle assessment of paper towels against electric hand driers and of wooden against mechanical pencils, and the triple bottom line; the environmental, social and economic impacts of five ways to generate 200 or 300 MW, rated high, medium or low; drinking-water treatment, first-order bacterial die-off, turbidity, a selenium mass balance, a 20-year water-demand forecast and the IPAT equation; and hazard and exposure, an inhalation cancer risk from trichloroethylene, the cancer risk and hazard quotient of arsenic in drinking water, definitions such as NOAEL and mutagen, and two Ontario Ministry of Labour case reports answered with controls at the source, along the path and at the worker. The notes add the waste hierarchy, design for environment, environmental impact assessment and the Canadian environmental and workplace law an answer may need to cite.
Both papers are 3 hours duration, but they differ on books and calculators. May 2019 is a closed-book exam: an approved Casio or Sharp calculator is permitted. December 2018 is an open book exam: any non-communicating calculator is permitted. On both, the name and model designation of the calculator is written on the exam book; any four (4) questions constitute an exam paper, and candidates indicate on the front of the exam booklet(s) which four questions were attempted, otherwise only the first four questions, as they appear in the answer book, will be marked; and all questions are of equal value, 25 marks each, split by part in the marking scheme on the front page. If a doubt exists as to the interpretation of any question, the candidate is urged to submit with the answer paper a clear statement of any assumptions made.
What this course gives you
Worked solutions — all ten questions, five from May 2019 and five from December 2018, every lettered part, set as live text and maths with the final answers pulled out ahead of the working, 48 figures and 17 further tables that lay out the working, and the papers' own data tables shown with the questions they belong to. Both sittings have a published solution that answers every part; each is transcribed as printed, and the figures, the added tables and the notes around it are written for this course, as are the corrected working, the rebuilt impact table of December 2018 Q3 and the clean before-and-after mass balance of May 2019 Q2(d). Every published step was checked, and fourteen that do not survive checking are flagged at the step that goes wrong, seven in each paper, each explained at that point with the published working quoted beside the correction. The largest are in the risk questions, which both published solutions get wrong on units. The trichloroethylene risk multiplies a dose by an air unit risk: 5.42×10⁻⁴ published against 1.9×10⁻³ for the residential exposure and 4.6×10⁻³ continuous in December 2018, and 4.4×10⁻⁴ against 1.5×10⁻³ and 3.7×10⁻³ in May 2019, not safe either way. The arsenic dose is carried in micrograms against a per-milligram slope factor, so the cancer risk comes out a thousand times too high — 0.148 published against 1.48×10⁻⁴ in December 2018, and 0.257 against 1.06×10⁻⁴ in May 2019 once the residential exposure factors of the paper's own Table 6.14 also replace an assumed 365 days a year for 70 years — and the hazard quotient goes from unsafe to acceptable, 493 against 0.77 and 571 against 0.55. The others: both CO₂e rankings are mislabelled (May 2019 calls SF₆, at 21.25 t the lowest, the highest; December 2018 calls N₂O, at 14,006 kg the highest, the lowest); the December 2018 Q3 impact table labels its fifth row coal where the paper asks for natural gas and contradicts its own explanations, so it is rebuilt; an example for the conserve-complexity principle incinerates or landfills computer chips; a water-demand forecast switches population between two lines (3.151 ML/d published, 3.138 corrected); a subtraction slip changes a conservation rate from 2.62 to 2.63 L per person per day each year; a mass-balance diagram draws end-of-pipe capture as pollution prevention; the life-cycle hot spots of paper towels and hand driers are put the wrong way round; and a definition calls ultraviolet light ionizing radiation. Nothing is silently overwritten. Study notes — ten condensed topics: sustainability, the triple bottom line and IPAT; air quality: ozone, particulates and acid rain; climate change, GWP and CO₂e; the 12 principles of green engineering; pollution prevention, the waste hierarchy and mass balances; life-cycle assessment and design for environment; electricity generation: comparing technologies; water: treatment, decay, mixing and demand; environmental health risk assessment; and hazard control and Canadian environmental law — with 29 figures and 14 tables between them, each topic naming the exam questions it serves. Practice & case studies — ten multiple-choice questions, each with a worked explanation, and five longer problems with complete worked answers and 13 figures between them: benzene in a residential well (dose, cancer risk and hazard quotient), a sewage outfall upstream of a swimming beach (mixing, then die-off), holding a growing town's water demand flat, and two case studies — disposable cups against office mugs as a streamlined LCA on illustrative carbon footprints, and a trichloroethylene degreaser in an Ontario plant (mass balance, exposure risk, the pollution-prevention hierarchy, controls and the laws that apply). All fifteen are written for this course; none is taken from the papers. Formula sheet — two pages, 35 relations in eight groups: greenhouse gases, air chemistry and concentration, exposure and dose, risk characterization, first-order decay, mass balance and mixing, growth and water demand, and sustainability and energy. Take it in when the sitting is open book, as December 2018 was; learn it when the sitting is closed book, as May 2019 was. Printable resources — ten one-page reference sheets written for this subject — the 12 principles of green engineering, an air quality and climate card, an LCA answer template, pollution prevention and mass balance, an energy technologies H/M/L matrix, water treatment, decay and demand, a risk assessment calculation card, hazard controls and Ministry of Labour case reports, a Canadian environmental law map, and an exam-day plan and question selector — plus four blank exam stationery templates. Reference links — sixteen selected reference websites, among them US EPA pages on ozone, acid rain and trichloroethylene, the IPCC tables behind the global warming potentials and the life-cycle emissions of electricity, Health Canada's drinking-water guidelines, the CCOHS hierarchy of controls, Ontario's Occupational Health and Safety Act, the Canadian Environmental Protection Act and the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada, and thirteen chosen YouTube videos, each with a note on what it covers. Practice papers — the two question papers on their own, unmarked, six pages each, for a timed three-hour run: answer any four questions.