Civ-A2 — Elementary Structural Design
Limit states design concepts. Loading due to use and occupancy, snow, wind, and earthquake. Design of tension members, beams, and columns in timber and steel. Design of timber connections and simple welded and bolted connections in steel. Design of determinate reinforced concrete beams and columns.
Subject outline
Civ-A2 Elementary Structural Design is a Civil Engineering technical exam (PEO National Examination 16-Civ-A2) on the limit states design of simple members and connections in steel, reinforced concrete and timber, to the Canadian design standards and the load combinations of the National Building Code. The May 2019 and December 2019 papers examine a built-up column of two back-to-back channels; a cantilevered W360x39 moment-connected to a continuous column, with its welded flange plates, bolted shear tab and lateral-torsional buckling check; a truss sized in square HSS, one size for every tension member and one for every compression member; a double-angle truss member with its interconnectors; a bolted shear connection and a fillet-welded splice for a W200x27; the ultimate moment of a composite W360x72 under a 100 mm slab, with its shear studs; the moment and shear resistance of two reinforced concrete T-beams; two slender square columns under axial load and wind, checked through the load combinations; two beams with overhangs designed for a factored load; and two built-up sawn-lumber beams in wet service, one with a snow drift and a wind load, the other with an overhang, a tip load and pattern loading. The study notes also cover what these two papers reach only in passing or not at all: snow, wind and earthquake loads, tension members with shear lag and block shear, section classes and web shear, and the O86 modification factors.
The paper is 3 hours and closed book. Both front pages state that this is a “CLOSED BOOK” examination: “Handbooks and textbooks are permitted. No notes or sheets are allowed.” Candidates may use one of two calculators, the Casio or Sharp approved models, and must write its name and model on the first inside left-hand sheet of the exam work book. “A total of five solutions are required. Only the first five as they appear in your answer book will be marked”: two questions from Part A (steel), two from Part B (reinforced concrete) and one from Part C (timber), whose only question is C1. If more than one solution is given for a question only the first is marked, and an answer you no longer wish to have graded is struck out with an “X”. “All questions within a given section are of equal value”, and the marking schemes give every question 20 marks, May 2019 A2 as 10 + 10 marks. Solutions must be to the latest editions of CAN/CSA S16 for steel, CAN/CSA A23.3 for concrete and CAN/CSA O86 for timber; “All loads shown are unfactored unless otherwise stated”; steel sections are G40.21 300W and reinforcement 400W unless noted otherwise; and where a question is open to interpretation the candidate is urged to submit “a clear statement of any reasonable assumptions made”.
What this course gives you
Worked solutions — all fourteen questions, seven from May 2019 and seven from December 2019, every part, fully retypeset as live text and maths, with the final answers pulled out ahead of the working, the eight figures printed on the official papers, 49 authored diagrams and charts set into the solutions (22 for May 2019, 27 for December 2019) — truss force diagrams, shear and moment diagrams, steel and composite sections, concrete sections with their strain and stress blocks, column interaction diagrams and utilisation charts — and 23 worked tables besides the fourteen final-answer tables. No official solution has been published for either paper, so every answer is written for this course from the question paper, to CSA S16, A23.3 and O86 and the NBCC load combinations, with the load combination, the resistance factors and every assumption stated, and every number checked by an independent recalculation. The papers print their questions as A1 to C1; the course numbers them 1 to 7 and opens each title with the printed label. Where a design check fails, it is flagged at the step that goes wrong: the 300 mm spacing of the 10M stirrups drawn in May 2019 B1 exceeds the 274.7 mm maximum, so its shear resistance of 202.5 kN is reported with that flag; the flange couple of May 2019 A2 overstresses the web panel of the W200x71 column, which takes a 6 mm doubler plate; above 227.1 kN the stirrup spacing limit of December 2019 B1 halves, so that T-beam can be relied on to 227.1 kN rather than its 240.6 kN strength; and the first trial of December 2019 B2, 4-20M, fails the wind combination 1.25D + 1.4W + 0.5L, so the column is designed with 4-25M. Where an answer turns on how the question is read, both readings are worked: the moment-gradient factor of the May 2019 A2 cantilever decides whether the W360x39 passes, at 176.6 kN·m against a factored moment of 170.2 kN·m, or fails, at 155.7 kN·m, and the December 2019 A3 composite beam is given with the newer concrete stress-block factor, 490.6 kN·m, and with the older 0.85, 494.3 kN·m. A design question has more than one acceptable answer, and the course says so. Study notes — ten condensed topics — limit states design, loads and load combinations; steel tension members, bolts and welds; steel compression members and built-up columns; steel beams, section class, lateral-torsional buckling and shear; steel moment connections, splices and column stiffening; composite steel-concrete beams; reinforced concrete beams in flexure, rectangles and T-beams; reinforced concrete shear design and detailing; reinforced concrete columns, interaction and slenderness; and timber design to O86, sawn and built-up members — each naming the May 2019 and December 2019 questions it serves, with 29 authored diagrams and charts and 15 tables between them. Practice & case studies — ten multiple-choice questions, each with a worked explanation, and five longer problems with complete worked answers and 13 figures: a double-angle tension member bolted to a gusset, lateral-torsional buckling of a W360x39 with and without a mid-span brace, a rectangular reinforced concrete beam designed from service loads, and two engineering case studies — the snow drift on a low roof built against a taller building, with its built-up SPF beams, and the wind on a roadside sign, with its square HSS post. Between them they reach the tension members and the NBCC snow and wind load calculations the two papers leave out. All fifteen are written for this course. Formula sheet — two pages, 44 relations in eight groups: loads and limit states; steel tension, bolts and welds; steel columns; steel beams and connections; composite beams; reinforced concrete beams; reinforced concrete columns; and timber beams. This closed-book exam admits handbooks and textbooks but no notes or sheets, so the sheet is for revision, to fix the methods and the factors in your head; in the exam room the handbooks carry the section properties and the tables. Printable resources — ten one-page reference cards — load combinations and resistance factors, the steel column curve and slenderness, steel beams with section class, lateral-torsional buckling and shear, bolts, welds and block shear, a composite beam quick card, concrete flexure for rectangles and T-beams, a concrete shear and detailing checklist, concrete columns with slenderness and P–M interaction, timber beams with the O86 factors, and an exam-day card on choosing your five — plus four blank exam stationery templates. Like the formula sheet, the cards are for study, not for the exam room. Reference links — thirteen selected reference websites, among them the Engineers Canada civil engineering syllabus, PEO's civil engineering exams page and its textbook list, the CISC Handbook of Steel Construction, the CSA store pages for S16, A23.3 and O86, the Cement Association of Canada's Concrete Design Handbook, the Canadian Wood Council's Wood Design Manual and the National Building Code of Canada with its structural commentaries, and fourteen selected YouTube videos, each with a note on which question it helps with. Practice papers — the two question papers on their own, unmarked, three pages each, for a timed three-hour run.